PFAS CERCLA Ruling: What CRE Lenders Need to Know

PFAS CERCLA regulatory update for commercial real estate lenders from LCS Inc.

PFAS CERCLA Ruling: The Forever Chemical Question Just Got a Permanent Answer

What the D.C. Circuit’s August 18 PFAS ruling means for lenders, credit teams, and CRE counsel

 

For two years, a lot of lenders treated PFAS as a problem they could keep in the parking lot — real, but not yet theirs. That parking lot just closed.

On August 18, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit decided Chamber of Commerce of the United States v. EPA, No. 24-1193, and denied every single petition challenging EPA’s 2024 rule designating PFOA and PFOS — two of the most widespread “forever chemicals” — as hazardous substances under CERCLA. Seven industry coalitions brought three separate lines of attack. All three failed. The designation stands.

For anyone underwriting, appraising, or closing commercial real estate, the practical question is not whether PFAS is now a CERCLA issue. It is. The question is what actually changes in your loan file on Monday morning — and what the court told us, sometimes between the lines, about how this is going to play out.

Here are the five takeaways that matter most.

1. This survived the hardest test available — and that makes it durable

The most important detail in the opinion is a procedural one that’s easy to skim past. Under Loper Bright, the court owed EPA no deference on the meaning of the statute. It read CERCLA § 102(a) independently, from scratch, and still concluded EPA had the better reading.

That matters for planning purposes. A rule upheld on deference is a rule that can wobble when the agency or the political weather changes. A rule upheld on the court’s own de novo reading of the text is considerably harder to unwind — by litigation or by a future administration. And it’s worth noting, this rule already got a second look: EPA paused the case in early 2025 to review the designation under new leadership, then affirmatively decided in September 2025 to keep it and defend it.

The specific fight was over the word “may”. Petitioners argued EPA had to show substantial danger will result from a release. The court answered that this rewrites the statute rather than interpreting it, and pointed out the obvious consequence: demanding absolute scientific certainty about every individual release would have paralyzed CERCLA from the day it was enacted.

Petitioners also floated the reductio — under EPA’s reading, why not designate table salt? The court wasn’t moved, and its answer is the sentence to remember: the statutory requirement of “substantial danger” has real bite, and requires a risk that is serious and real, not hypothesized. That phrase is now the operative limiting principle for every future designation.

2. Liability is not automatic — the court mapped a long, contingent road to it

If you take one piece of reassurance from this opinion, take this one. A substantial stretch of the decision is devoted to walking through everything that has to happen before any party gets a cleanup bill, and the list is long: Hazard Ranking System scoring, National Priorities List placement through its own notice-and-comment rulemaking, a remedial site evaluation under the National Contingency Plan, a remedial action plan with a mandatory cost-effectiveness analysis, and a second round of notice and comment — all before liability questions even arise.

Layered on top of that are CERCLA’s own limits: covered-person requirements, complete defenses for acts of God and third-party acts, de minimis and de micromis protections for small contributors, a statutory instruction that EPA prioritize settlement over litigation, and — the one your borrowers will care about — innocent landowner protection for purchasers with no knowledge of contamination at the time of purchase.

 

BY THE NUMBERS — FROM EPA’S RECORD, AS CITED BY THE COURT

•  Roughly 3% — share of the 53,400 sites assessed since 1980 that have actually landed on the National Priorities List.

•  133 — non-NPL sites EPA identified as highest-likelihood for PFOA/PFOS contamination. EPA assumed enforcement at about half.

•  16–17 — non-NPL sites per year where EPA projected initiating enforcement, citing resource constraints.

•  $10.3M–$51.7M — EPA’s estimated incremental per-site cleanup cost range at NPL sites attributable to the designation.

•  2%–10% — the marginal cost premium EPA modeled for adding PFOA/PFOS to an existing cleanup. Petitioners argued for 5%–100%; the court found EPA’s rejection of the high end reasonable.

•  800+ — substances already designated hazardous under CERCLA. PFOA and PFOS, as the court put it, are two drops in that bucket.

 

The honest read: federal enforcement volume is likely to be modest and slow. But “slow federal enforcement” is a very different thing from “no exposure.” The designation also opens the door to state actions and private cost-recovery and contribution claims — and those don’t wait in EPA’s queue.

3. The reporting obligations, by contrast, are immediate and unconditional

The court identified three direct impacts of the designation that involve no contingency and no discretion at all:

  • Release reporting. Any party responsible for a release of more than one pound of PFOA or PFOS in a 24-hour period must report it to the National Response Center — and in some circumstances to state and local authorities and the public.
  • Federal property transfers. Federal agencies selling contaminated land must generally disclose the presence of hazardous substances — relevant to any deal touching former military, GSA, or other federal parcels.
  • Shipments over one pound must be identified and marked under the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act.

That one-pound threshold deserves a second look, particularly for borrowers running wastewater treatment, landfill, biosolids, plating, or firefighting-foam operations. It is a low bar, and a missed report is a compliance failure independent of whether anyone is ever asked to fund a cleanup.

4. The court didn’t analyze real estate impacts — and its reason should get your attention

Petitioners specifically argued that EPA failed to consider the designation’s unintended consequences for real estate transactions. The court rejected the argument, but read carefully how: EPA didn’t need to conduct an individualized analysis of the real estate market, because it had already addressed liability limitations generally — including protection for innocent landowners with no knowledge of contamination at the time of purchase.

In other words, the court’s answer to “what about property transactions?” was, in substance, “the statutory landowner defenses handle that.”

Here is the part the opinion doesn’t say, because it didn’t have to: those defenses are not automatic. Innocent landowner status, bona fide prospective purchaser status, and contiguous property owner protection all require that the buyer conducted all appropriate inquiries into prior ownership and use before acquisition — which in practice means a compliant Phase I Environmental Site Assessment. The court just leaned on those protections as the reason real-world transaction impacts would be manageable. That reasoning only holds for parties who actually earned them.

This is the single most important operational consequence of the ruling for lenders and their counsel. The defense that makes PFAS survivable in a CRE transaction is a diligence-conditioned defense — and the scoping decision that determines whether you have it is made at order entry, weeks before anyone reads a report.

 

THE SCOPING QUESTION TO ASK ON EVERY DEAL NOW

Because PFOA and PFOS are CERCLA hazardous substances, they now fall within the universe of substances a Phase I ESA is designed to identify — they are no longer an optional “emerging contaminant” add-on outside the standard scope.

But a Phase I is a records-and-reconnaissance exercise. It does not sample. Confirming PFAS presence requires Phase II sampling, and field practice, screening levels, and lab protocols are still maturing across states.

The practical result: on properties with a plausible PFAS use history, the decision about whether to carry the finding into Phase II sampling is a judgment call — and it is a judgment call that should be made deliberately, documented in the file, and not defaulted.

 

Property histories that should trigger a closer look

PFOA and PFOS turn up in predictable places. Any of the following in a site’s chain of use is worth flagging at scoping:

  • Airports, military installations, refineries, and fire training facilities — aqueous film-forming foam (AFFF) is the classic source
  • Textile, leather, carpet, and paper or packaging coating operations — stain, water, and grease resistance
  • Metal plating and finishing, particularly chrome plating
  • Landfills and transfer stations, including construction and demolition debris facilities
  • Wastewater treatment plants — and, critically, agricultural or open land where treated biosolids were land-applied
  • Properties downgradient of any of the above, where groundwater is the pathway

That last category is the one that surprises people. A clean parcel with an unremarkable history can still sit in a plume. The court’s own record notes PFAS persist for hundreds of years in the environment — a prior owner’s activity from the 1970s is not a historical footnote here, it’s a present condition.

5. The reasoning clears a path for the next designations

PFOA and PFOS are two compounds out of a family that runs into the thousands. This ruling validated not just the outcome, but the analytical framework EPA used to get there — hazard plus environmental fate and transport, assessed against a “may present substantial danger” standard that requires possibility rather than certainty. It also rejected the nondelegation and vagueness challenges that would have constrained EPA going forward.

Two related threads are worth watching over the next several quarters:

  • A framework rule for future designations. EPA has signaled it intends to propose a general framework governing how it designates additional hazardous substances — which would set the terms for any further PFAS listings.
  • The passive receiver question. Water utilities, landfills, airports, and farms that received PFAS-containing material without manufacturing it filed as amici here, and the issue remains unresolved through enforcement policy rather than through this opinion. If your borrower base includes municipal utilities or waste operators, this is the thread to track.
  • A possible cert petition. Petitioners have signaled they are weighing next steps. The only remaining route is the Supreme Court, which would have to agree to take the case. Until and unless that happens, the designation is fully effective and enforceable.

 

What to actually do about it

A short, unglamorous list. Most of this is scoping discipline rather than new spend.

Where What changes
Phase I scoping Confirm your ESA provider is treating PFOA and PFOS as in-scope CERCLA hazardous substances, not as an optional emerging-contaminant rider. Ask how they document the decision when a PFAS use history is identified but sampling is not recommended.
Credit policy Add PFAS-plausible use histories to the list of conditions that trigger senior review or a Phase II decision — AFFF sites, plating, textiles, landfills, biosolids-applied land, and downgradient parcels.
Loan documents Review environmental representations, indemnities, and the definition of “hazardous substances” in your form docs. Definitions tied to a static list may not capture post-2024 designations. Definitions tied to CERCLA by reference will.
Construction lending Fill material, imported soil, and C&D debris are the exposure points. Verify source documentation for imported fill on ground-up projects, and build the check into your draw process rather than the closing checklist.
Appraisal & valuation Where a PFAS condition is identified or plausible, the valuation assignment should address it explicitly — including remediation cost assumptions and any market-perceived stigma. An appraisal silent on a known condition is a weak exhibit in an exam file.
Existing portfolio This designation took effect in July 2024. Loans underwritten before then were diligenced against a Phase I scope that did not include these substances. A targeted look-back on your highest-risk property types is a reasonable exercise — not a portfolio-wide fire drill.
Exam file Document the scoping rationale, not just the result. The value of a diligence file under CERCLA is that it demonstrates inquiry was appropriate. Reasoning that lives only in someone’s inbox does not do that work.

 

The bottom line

The D.C. Circuit didn’t make PFAS a bigger problem than it was on August 17. What it did was remove the last plausible reason to wait. The designation is settled, it survived review without the benefit of deference, and the landowner defenses the court pointed to as the safety valve are available only to parties who did the diligence before they closed.

Which is, in the end, a familiar story. CERCLA has always rewarded the borrower and the lender who asked the right questions early and wrote down the answers. This ruling just added two more chemicals to the list of things worth asking about.

 

HOW LCS CAN HELP

Our environmental team scopes Phase I and Phase II assessments around your credit policy and the specific risk profile of the property — including PFAS use histories, plume proximity, and the sampling decision when it matters.

We also coordinate environmental, valuation, and construction risk on the same deal, so a PFAS finding gets read against the appraisal and the construction budget rather than landing in three separate reports on three separate clocks.

 

Ready to Talk? 

To learn more, reach out to Liz Mahoney, SVP & Director of Sales & Business Development today. 

Explore our services 

Contact us to support your project’s success. 

EMAIL LIZ CALL LIZ

About the author: Liz Mahoney is SVP & Director of Sales and Business Development at Lender Consulting Services, VP of the Mortgage Bankers Association of New York, a 2x GlobeSt. 2026 Woman of Influence award recipient, and host of The Smarter Lending Podcast. 

Source: Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America, et al. v. EPA, No. 24-1193 (D.C. Cir. Aug. 18, 2026) (Millett, J.), consolidated with Nos. 24-1261, 24-1266, 24-1271, 24-1272, denying petitions for review of Designation of Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA) and Perfluorooctanesulfonic Acid (PFOS) as CERCLA Hazardous Substances, 89 Fed. Reg. 39,124 (May 8, 2024).

This article is provided by Lender Consulting Services, Inc. for general informational purposes and reflects our reading of a recent judicial decision as of the date of publication. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client or consultant-client relationship. Environmental liability under CERCLA is fact-specific. Consult qualified legal counsel and a licensed environmental professional regarding any particular property or transaction.